Less Is More: The Hidden Cost of Too Many Choices in Restaurants

By PDM Hospitality Solutions

If you want to make it difficult to earn a profit, try being everything to everyone.

Walk into many restaurants today and look at the choices.

A menu with 60 or 70 items. A bar stocked with 20 bourbons, 15 tequilas, 30 beers, and a wine list featuring 100 selections.

My question is simple.

Why?

Does offering more choices automatically generate more sales? Or does it create unnecessary inventory, additional labor, and money sitting on shelves?

With today's operating costs, perhaps it's time to reconsider the idea that more is always better.

Does Every Selection Justify Its Existence?

Recently, I stopped at Taco Bell and ordered a taco and a diet soda.

The employee asked, "What kind?"

I replied, "Diet soda."

Then came the choices: Diet Coke, Diet Pepsi, Diet Dr Pepper, and another diet selection.

I laughed. I wasn't there for the extensive beverage selection. I wanted a taco and something diet to drink.

Of course, customers have preferences, and some additional choices cost very little to offer. But every product requires some level of purchasing, stocking, and management.

The question isn't whether customers enjoy choices. It's whether those choices justify their cost.

How Much Money Is Sitting on Your Shelves?

Consider a restaurant offering 100 wines.

If it stocks an average of four bottles of each wine at a wholesale cost of $25 per bottle, that's $10,000 in inventory.

Reduce the selection to 30 carefully chosen wines, maintaining the same stock level, and the investment drops to $3,000.

That's potentially $7,000 in working capital freed up without necessarily sacrificing meaningful sales.

The same thinking applies behind the bar.

Does a neighborhood restaurant really need 20 bourbons, 15 tequilas, and 40 beers?

If five bourbons account for nearly all bourbon sales, what are the others contributing?

Every slow-moving product occupies space, requires inventory management, and ties up money.

I'm not suggesting that every restaurant should carry the same limited selection. A bourbon-focused bar may need 50 bourbons, and a fine-dining restaurant may benefit from an extensive wine cellar.

Your inventory should reflect your customers and your concept, not everything your distributor offers.

Have We Made Cocktails Too Complicated?

I spent many years behind the bar, including working as a head bartender.

We made wonderful drinks using relatively few ingredients. Grasshoppers, Pink Squirrels, Martinis, Manhattans, and other classics were attractive, delicious, and efficient to prepare.

Today, some cocktails require eight or ten ingredients, including specialty products used in only one drink.

How long does the drink take to prepare? How often does it sell? How much inventory is required to support it?

I'm not against creativity. But a cocktail should contribute to sales and profitability, not simply add complexity.

A great cocktail is one customers enjoy, bartenders can prepare consistently, and the restaurant can sell profitably.

A Lesson I Learned Selling Restaurant Equipment

Years ago, when I sold restaurant equipment, tableware, and supplies, I made a mistake that taught me an important lesson.

I would visit customers with numerous plate and silverware selections, believing more choices would make their decisions easier.

Instead, I frequently confused them.

They would study all the options, struggle to decide, and sometimes ask me to return with something different.

Eventually, I changed my approach.

I learned about the customer's operation, determined what would work best, and presented three or four carefully selected options.

Making the sale became much easier.

My responsibility wasn't to show customers everything available. It was to guide them toward the right decision.

Restaurants should approach their menus, beverage programs, and purchasing decisions the same way.

Let Your Sales Reports Make the Decisions

The 80/20 principle is a useful starting point. Often, a relatively small percentage of products generates a large share of sales.

Review your POS reports.

  • Which menu items generate the most sales and gross profit?
  • Which wines, beers, and spirits actually move?
  • Which specialty ingredients are rarely used?
  • Which products would customers genuinely miss if eliminated?

Don't eliminate products blindly. Some slower-selling items may be important to your concept or customer loyalty.

But don't continue carrying products simply because you've always carried them.

Every item should earn its place in your operation.

Your Storeroom Is Full of Money

Every bottle, case of beer, specialty ingredient, and slow-moving menu product represents money already spent.

And the expense doesn't stop with purchasing.

Products must be received, stored, counted, rotated, and managed. Some deteriorate, expire, or never sell.

Reducing inventory by $10,000 doesn't create $10,000 in additional profit. But it can free up cash for payroll, equipment repairs, or other operating needs.

Reducing unnecessary products can also simplify employee training, food preparation, storage, and purchasing.

That's where the benefits extend beyond inventory.

Stop Trying to Be Everything to Everyone

Maybe your restaurant doesn't need 100 wines.

Maybe five carefully selected bourbons are enough.

Maybe 12 beers will satisfy nearly all your customers.

Maybe your 60-item menu could become 25 exceptional dishes.

And maybe your employees could provide better service with fewer products to prepare, stock, and manage.

The objective isn't to eliminate choice simply to reduce inventory.

It's to eliminate choices that don't generate enough value to justify their cost.

Before adding another menu item, liquor brand, wine, or specialty ingredient, ask two questions:

Will this product generate enough additional profit to justify carrying it?

If I eliminated it tomorrow, how many customers would actually miss it?

Sometimes the most profitable decision a restaurant can make isn't deciding what to add.

It's deciding what to take away.

PDM Hospitality Solutions

Systems • Solutions • Training

Practical hospitality solutions backed by decades of hands-on experience in restaurant operations, culinary management, purchasing, equipment, and staff training.